Player ratings and match stats from Exeter City 1 Rotherham United 0

This was the Millers’ worst performance of the season by a long way

Paul Davis gives his verdict on League Two events at St James Park on Saturday.

Marvin Kaleta in action for Rotherham United at Exeter Cityplaceholder image
Marvin Kaleta in action for Rotherham United at Exeter City | Jim Brailsford

Millers (4-3-3)

Julian Eyestone: 5

Distribution poor, decision-making hit and miss, handling fine, shot-stopping okay.

Denzel Hall: 5

One of the better Millers players on a day when most players were far below their best. Timed his tackles well and was composed on the ball, but Exeter goal's came down his side.

Sonny Aljofree: 5

His least-assured display since joining the club. Not the commanding figure we have become used to. Didn't know whether to stick or twist at times.

Dominic Iorfa: 5

Made a superb goal-saving block early on. After that, he was a mixed bag. There were some strong moments but others where he could have been more authoritative.

Kieran Ngwenya: 4

Was at fault for the goal, when he let Anthony Scully slip in front of him to poke the ball home, and generally looked uneasy in a left-back role.

Josh Austerfield: 4

The first poor performance from the new boy after a series of decent wins. Usually, he hunts down second balls, but City were first to nearly everything all afternoon. No lack of effort but there was a lack of impact.

Ossama Ashley: 4

A huge drop-off after being at the top of his game in recent weeks. Looked lethergic, and didn't compete hard enough on a day when all of Rotherham's midfielders weren't 'at' it. Exeter's Taylor Perry had a field day against them.

Jayce Fitzgerald: 4

Got and gave the ball, but to no real effect, and didn't do enough out of possession to stop the Grecians. Not involved enough, and never hurt the opposition going forward. Lessons to be learned for the talented loanee.

Marvin Kaleta: 6

The one player who could look himself in the eye at the final whistle and be content with his performance. On his first league start after a spell out injured, he was a threat on the right flank with his crosses and clever little passes. One burst through Exeter's midfield that saw him beat three players showcased his potential. More to come from him.

Paul Mullin: 5

Worked hard but his finishing was off. Didn't get enough service.

Jili Buyabu: 3

Capable of being devastating, capable of being dismal. Sadly, it was the latter here. Looked like his mind was wandering further than his body as he failed to get to grips with himself.

The subs

Kian Spence (for Ngwenya 70): NA

One of the Millers' best players has seemed a little out of sorts since his return from injury. Did more without the ball than with it at St James Park.

Tom Bradshaw (for Fitzgerald 58): 4

The visitors were struggling when he came and continued to struggle.

Aaron Nemane (for Kaleta 70): 4

Left out of the 11 after a run of starts. Didn't do enough as a substitute to guarantee he won't be on the bench again for the next league match.

Not used: Ted Cann, Joe Rafferty, Emmanuel Adegboyega, Hamish Douglas.

Exeter (4-3-2-1): Jack Bycroft 6; Lakyle Samuel 7, Jack Taylor 7, Jack Fitzwater 7, Luca Woodhouse 7; Taylor Perry 9, Jake Doyle Hayes 6, Charlie Cummins 7; Anthony Scully 7 (Gwion Edwards 65, 7), George Birch 8 (Ethan Sutherland 80); Josh Gordon 7 (Sonny Cox 85). Subs not used: Frankie Phillips, Harry Kite, Liam Oakes, Louie Cayless.

Goals: Scully 51 (Exeter)

Referee: Lewis Sandoe (Dorset)

Attendance: 5,631 (310)

Opposition view

"We got box entries and bodies in the box. That’s something we’ve not done enough this season. We were really determined in those moments of the game. It’s such a well-taken goal.

"I can’t remember Rotherham creating too much over the course of the afternoon, but they’ve got pace and you’ve always got to be wary of their threats.

"We’d have liked more in terms of the scoreline, and maybe our performance deserved that. We missed opportunities to make it more than 1-0.

"The lads were in the right positions, which pleased me the most. We’ve been so strong defensively, but our attacking output still needs improvement.

"We can keep clean sheets. That’s important for this group of players. And now they know how to see out a game."

- Matt Taylor

The stats

Possession: Exeter 48 per cent, Milles 52

Goal attempts: Exeter 16, Millers 7

On target: Exeter 7, Millers 1

Touches in opposition box: Exeter 22, Millers 14

Corners: Exeter 8, Millers 2

Fouls committed: Exeter 8, Millers 13

Final word

A lack of application and character, which is the first time that accusation has been levelled at the team this term.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice