Player ratings ... how Rotherham United’s first-teamers have fared so far

‘He's doing what he was brought in to do and providing a masterclass in different types of finishes in the process. ‘

Nearly a third of the League Two season has passed by already.

Paul Mullin has been finding the net for Rotherham Unitedplaceholder image
Paul Mullin has been finding the net for Rotherham United | Jim Brailsford

As Rotherham United prepare to resume their campaign after the international break, here's how their players have fared so far.

The list is restricted to those who have been in regular first-team contention when fit.

Goalkeepers

Ted Cann: 5

In, out, then in again. The Millers have yet to truly decide on their number one, which says something about the form of both contenders for the jersey. Cann makes good saves, but also has unforgiving hands that too often spill the ball into the path of an opposition player. His handling is hit and miss and his kicking needs work.

Julian Eyestone: 5

Out, in, then out again. Capable of very good stuff, but not all the time. We need to remember how young the loanee is. This is an experienced boy still learning what's required in the men's. He's 'softer' and better in his handling than Cann, but the 20-year-old needs to up his physicality and improve his decision-making.

There are times when he doesn't release the ball quickly enough to get his side moving forward - and that's a failing that can also be laid at his rival's door.

Defenders

Denzel Hall: 8

A slow-ish start is turning into a very good campaign for the Dutchman. Way, way too classy for the fourth tier. As soon as he upped his application, he began to stand out. Whether he's played as a right-back, a wing-back, a centre-half or left-back, he's impressed in every role. He does the right things, looks after the ball and has problem-solving pace on the odd occasions he finds himself in trouble.

Joe Rafferty: 5

You have to feel for a top bloke and a willing servant of the club. The captain had just forced his way back into the side when he was hit by an injury - in his 500th career appearance - that has, in all likelihood, ended his season. His nous, keep-it-simple approach and nurturing of other players had improved the backline. Only his lack of matches this term keeps his score down.

Rotherham United new boy Sonny Aljofree has plenty of attributesplaceholder image
Rotherham United new boy Sonny Aljofree has plenty of attributes | Jim Brailsford

Sonny Aljofree: 7

There's a proper player in the making with this youngster. All that he needs is more toughness and more matches under his belt. Everything else is already in his locker. Began the season strongly, suffered a dip and then climbed back to his best. That shows he has a bit of character.

Dominic Iorfa: 7

On a individual level, he hasn't been found wanting at all. The centre-half has spent most of his career in the Championship and that pedigree has shown, even though he is still working towards full match fitness. There are shades of Semi Ajayi about him in the way he covers the ground so smoothly and how quick he is to close down opponents. He doesn't get beaten one on one. However, he hasn't picked up the backline by the scruff of the neck and brought everything together, which is what we were all hoping he would do. Maybe he's just not that type of player. More Semi than Woody.

Kieran Ngwenya: 6

Quietly and unfussily, he puts up a fight every time he takes to the pitch. There are flaws that need some work - he's sometimes slow to react and can be beaten by a bit of trickery - but he is a wholehearted competitor whose commitment to the cause is unquestionable.

Emmanuel Adegboyega: 4

He has admirable physical capabilities but hasn't put them all together at the same time on enough occasions. That's cost him his place and he hasn't featured in a league fixture for two months. He needs to make his mind as strong as his body, because there's been a tendency to lose concentration and make poor decisions.

Lenny Agbaire: 4

He was a first-choice selection at the start of the campaign, but injury sidelined him for a while and he has been confined to bench duty since his return to fitness.

Hamish Douglas: 4

A young player who just can't get going this season, bless him. He showed real potential last term, but there were injuries back then, and another one in pre-season wrecked his chance of staking a claim for a place in the starting 11. He didn't play until late September and has made a couple of high-profile mistakes that have led to opposition goals. He needs a run of games to settle himself down, but the fear is, those matches might not be coming his way now that other centre-backs have pushed in front of him

Ewan Otoo: 7

The summer signing had rapidly become a very important player because of his ability to perform solidly in a number of different positions. He's out until the new year through injury, and he is a big, big miss.

Brandon Williams: 6

The eternal trialist until Rotherham finally offered him a deal in late October. They needed a left-back as they switched from a back three to a back four and he fitted the bill. He's yet to hit the standards he once set with Manchester United before his off-field troubles, but there has been an improvement in him in all of his four games so far.

Midfielders

Kian Spence: 6

I just wish he could put a run of matches together and really get his Millers career going. Injuries and, now, a suspension have prevented him doing that. For my money, he's one of the best all-round midfielders in the division. He can run (boy, he can run), he can do plenty on the ball, he's a 'ratter' who unsettles opponents and he has the right kind of nasty streak in him. Please, stay fit. Please, don't see red again.

Brandon Cover: 7

The Jamaica international isn't brilliant at any one thing, but he's not poor in any department either. A bits-and-pieces player with a good engine who, to his credit, has made himself a regular starter. He's deserved the amount of game time he's had.

Josh Austerfield has done well since his summer move from Salford Cityplaceholder image
Josh Austerfield has done well since his summer move from Salford City | Jim Brailsford

Josh Austerfield: 7

He's turning out to be one of the best signings of the 17 made during boss Alex Bruce's tenure. Another player who has no trouble covering the ground, going forwards or backwards, and he's a competitor who gets himself on to plenty of second ball. His passing and crossing has a subtle deftness to it sometimes, too.

Ossama Ashley: 6

At his best, he's given 8/10 performances. At his worst, there have been 4/10 displays. So, 6/10 seems about right. He's capable of stopping the opposition and dictating play as a defensive midfielder and he can also have an effect higher up the position. There's a lot in his locker, and he needs to take more of it out when he gets back from injury.

Jayce Fitzgerald: 8

Rotherham's standout player in the last few weeks. He's only 19, and the Manchester United loanee, in his first year of senior football, won't be spending much of his career at this level. He gets the ball, keeps the ball and does all the right things with the ball. What a talent.

Jamie Jellis: 4

Another player on the end of a low mark through no fault of his own. He showed up better than anyone in pre-season friendlies, but two serious injuries have prevented him making an impact since the real stuff began. It could be 2027 before he gets the chance to make up for lost time.

Wingers

Aaron Nemane: 7

He wasn't a regular starter as the season got under way, but he's found the attacking spark that made him a promotion-winner in League Two with MK Dons last season. His devastating acceleration has left opponents for dead in a matter of yards and, more and more, there has been an end product to his speed and trickery. One of the first names on the team sheet now. Don't ask him to defend, mind - that's not his thing!

Jili Buyabu has talent, but his red card angered the club and fansplaceholder image
Jili Buyabu has talent, but his red card angered the club and fans | Jim Brailsford

Jili Buyabu: 5

He offers so much, yet sometimes delivers much too little, and that elbow at Swindon Town might finish up being the Sheffield United loanee's headline act. He needs to win back the respect of fans, teammates and staff when he resumes playing at the conclusion of his three-match ban. That's if he's ever trusted to pull on a Millers shirt again - Bruce is still deciding what comes next. The problem is mental, not physical. There's a very dangerous wide player there if he can cut out the stupidity.

Marvin Kaleta: 4

Rotherham have an explosive talent on their hands if he can stay out of the treatment room for a meaningful period. Sadly, he couldn't do that in his first year at AESSEAL New York Stadium, and, so far, it's proving to be beyond him in his second.

Attackers

Paul Mullin: 8

Eight good reasons for an 8 rating … that's the number of goals he's already bagged this season. He's doing what he was brought in to do and providing a masterclass in different types of finishes in the process. The hard work he puts in is a bonus.

Tom Bradshaw: 6

There's still life in old legs. He's been quiet in some games, but there have also been so sharp, telling contributions. The 34-year-old knows his way around the final third of the pitch and matches Mullin for effort.

Fabio Tavares: 7

He's out injured until next season, and his absence is as big a blow at Otoo's unavailability. He decorated rather than dominated games before rupturing his Achilles tendon, but within that there were game-affecting moments of quality. Rotherham's drop-off in form coincided with him going out of the team in late September. A player who could make ground with the ball and do something with it, he was bringing out the best in Buyabu on the left flank as the pair had struck up a good understanding.

George Sebine: 6

The young Huddersfield Town loanee could become a key contributor because he's the only forward other than Tavares capable of running in behind defences. He's big and quick, and his display at Bromley in the FA Cup showed he has fully recovered from a calf problem. There's more to come from him.

Klaidi Lolos: 6

He's offering the Millers something different at the top end of the pitch now that he's clear of the thigh complaint that sidelined him after his deadline-day loan arrival. A '10' role suits him because he has the skill to bring other players into the game. He's far from the fastest runner in the squad. However, the speed of his brain makes up for it. He may or may not deliver over the course of a season. However, the possibilities surrounding him are intriguing. He was effective as substitute at Bromley and needs to build on that contribution.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice