One rebuild after another threatens EFL status... The Tom Eyre Rotherham United Fan Column
‘In the same games, we are either excellent or dreadful.’
Too good to go down, too weak to stay up.


The truth is, if a few less mistakes were made, and a few more critical moments went our way, we could be talking about a promotion push going into January. Instead, we are looking over our shoulder at the abyss outside of the EFL.
The same questions were asked of Matt Hamshaw’s team, and they failed to answer them with any conviction. We were the second-worst team in one of the worst League One campaigns I can remember.
But, like this year, we didn’t have to be. It was still, even towards the end, within our capabilities to have been pushing for the top half of the division.
Our ceiling is at the top of this league. Instead, we are staring at relegation again because that is where our floor is - in the same games, we are either excellent or dreadful. There is no middle ground.
Compare this with the vast majority of other League Two sides and you see the problem. With the greatest of respect, the teams in this division are rarely excellent, nor are they consistently dreadful. They won’t be outfought or outgunned, they will stick to their plan, and they will scrap for points and wins when not at their best.
Now you look at us, a side rebuilding for the third season in a row - with players brought in for a different manager, some players still learning their trade and others with obvious talent but large inconsistencies - and you can see why we aren’t in that conversation.
Mix this in with an inexperienced head coach still finding his feet in the managerial world and there is an uneasy reminder of last season where, for a while, we lived in blind faith that we were too good to go down.
So, here we are, 12 months on from the most disastrous centenary year that a football fan can endure, and what have we learned? What has changed to ensure that last season’s mistakes are left in the past? Not a great deal.
The answer is another rebuild; the answer is always another rebuild - another season of ripping up the blueprint and hoping something sticks, doomed to making the same mistakes time and time again.
Steve McClaren was brought in as a fix to steady the downward trajectory, leaving Alex Bruce to manage the meagre squad he inherited and integrate the players we could attract.
The outcome is another rebuild with flaws and brittleness, and still the people at the top shun the accountability, responsibility and transformative change required.
Maybe the cogs are turning, maybe Phil Smith’s comments for a change, and a shake-up, haven’t fallen on deaf ears.
Or maybe they have. And if these obvious issues at the club continue to be ignored, Millers fans' memories of the EFL will become a distant ones.