Good bits, bad bits during a work in progress … the David Rawson Rotherham United fan column
FOOTBALL is a pretty all-or-nothing sort of game.
There’s none of this rugby nonsense, where you get more points if you score one way than you do if you score another. In football, you score or you don’t. You win or you lose.


There’s no credit for style. It doesn’t matter how well you play, how the match unfolds, whether your luck was in or not.
It’s definitive. You’re good, or you’re not.
Us, this season so far? Well, we’re definitely not good. But, equally, we’re not that bad, either.
We’re prone to lapses of concentration, especially when crosses come into our box. We’re a bit weak physically (in general, and particularly given the injuries we have). We’re a little bit too steady in possession. It feels like we need a bit of spark and fizz, a bit of real “go” in our play.
At the same time, we’ve played some really good stuff. The second goal against Wigan, for example, was a really slick, well-worked piece of football. There’s been at least a part of every game where we’ve controlled the flow of play.
The first part of the equation outweighs the second, though, so far. Start on top at Doncaster, make them make mistakes. Then don’t block a fairly routine cross, don’t stop a fairly standard charge to be on the end of it, and lose another game where there’s not much in it.
Some years, you’re no good. You can tell those years from the off. All you can do when they come round is try to stick with it as much as you can and hope that it’s that one-in-50 sort of season where a team that’s no good somehow manages to stay up regardless.
This is not one of those years. If this season turns out to be a struggle (and teams who play okay, don’t take their chances and then lose fairly even games because they can’t defend tend to struggle), it will be because the team will be less than the sum of its parts.
Just like last year. Which maybe makes sense, given some of the parts we are trying to make add up are the same.
A work in progress is like this. There’ll be bits of good and bits of bad.
Remember, we made a handbrake turn in the summer and still haven’t got full control of the car. It’s too much to expect to be speeding off into the distance.
We just need to make sure that we don’t stall. Because this week we did a decent amount of work, but we didn’t show much progress.
Five games in, you’d hope for a bit more.