Big month needed to exorcise the ghosts ... The David Rawson Rotherham United Fan Column
Reasons for optimism, reasons for concern
New season, new division, new team.


Same story.
In a way, I wish we’d played worse. I wish we’d looked more like the team we know we are, stitched together at the last minute and still without the number of players a full squad requires these days.
I thought we’d beat Cheltenham. Perhaps they’ll prove to be one of the best sides in the division, and Whaddon Road will be one of the toughest away trips out there. But I’m not convinced.
On paper, they looked beatable. On grass, they appeared that way, too. They were fairly solid, well-organised and disciplined. That was about it.
We controlled the game for large periods. There was a flow to some of our moves. Our goal involved a lovely switch of pace of play, finished coolly by a young player making his league debut who looked like a seasoned professional in his time on the pitch.
But we still didn’t win. Still found a way to lose.
It’s credit to the coaching team that we looked as coherent as we did. But that’s a double-edged compliment. Do players still lack match sharpness? Certainly. But will we get hugely better than that in terms of performance? I’m not so sure.
Cheltenham let us have the ball, blocked us out (somewhat fortunately) and then took their chances when they came. They were lucky to win, sure, but how often did we say that last season?
It doesn’t look like we’re going to out-muscle opponents. We don’t have the height or physique. We can’t go route one.
We’re all in on out-footballing teams. The good news is, we look able to do it.
We just need it to click. We just need to keep confident. Then we’ll be fine.
Which is, of course, what we said last season. And the season before that.
Let’s assume York and Chesterfield are way better than Cheltenham. What happens if we’re three games in, winless and confidence is dented? If we need an ugly nil-nil away to stick a wedge in, have we got the brute force and bloody-mindedness to deliver it? I wonder.
And I think what we saw from Cheltenham - a limited set of opponents sitting off, blocking out and waiting to pounce on any mistake - is likely to be the model for a lot of this season. And it worked too well against a version of us that was nearer to full throttle than I thought was likely.
If we had a proper “big lad up front” and an old-fashioned out-and-out stopper at the back, I’d be happier. Add the option of some old-school pragmatism to this mix and we might be a real force.
On that showing, this team could be impressive. But the ghosts of seasons past lurk ominously. We need a strong month to ward them off.