Rotherham man fractured eye socket of cousin days prior to alleged murder, jury told

A jury was told that a man accused of murdering his cousin had assaulted him a couple of days prior to the alleged incident.

A 55-year-old man is on trial for allegedly murdering his cousin while camping on wasteland in Rotherham.

Wayne White, of Shakespeare Road, Rotherham, went camping with his cousin on May 31 2025 at a campsite behind warehouses off Waddington Way, Parkgate.

Found unresponsive: Garry Claydon was found on Waddington Way in Parkgate, Rotherham on the morning of Sunday, June 1, 2025. Almost a year later, his cousin, Wayne White, was charged with his alleged murderplaceholder image
Found unresponsive: Garry Claydon was found on Waddington Way in Parkgate, Rotherham on the morning of Sunday, June 1, 2025. Almost a year later, his cousin, Wayne White, was charged with his alleged murder | South Yorkshire Police

But in the early hours of the following morning, Garry Claydon, aged 54, was found unresponsive.

At Sheffield Crown Court on Monday November 16, White’s trial continued as he stands accused of assaulting his cousin in an attack which broke his ribs and fatally punctured his lung.

The prosecution’s case is that after both men were seen on CCTV shortly after midnight on June 1 buying cheeseburgers from McDonald's - they both returned to their campsite through a hole in a fence and didn’t leave the area again for six hours.

In that time, it is alleged that White assaulted Garry, resulting in his death.

Mr Nicholas Worsley KC, prosecuting, said: “He gave him a beating.”

He also told the jury that after the events had allegedly took place, White had “swelling” to his right hand.

White denies assaulting his cousin, and claims his cousin was attacked in the night by another party after leaving the campsite shortly after they got back from McDonald’s.

Mr Worsley told the jury that on May 30, a couple of days prior to this incident, White thought Garry had taken his cannabis, so he “attacked him - punched him three times”, which fractured his right eye socket.

A further history of assault was mentioned too - including one incident in April 2025 where White grabbed his cousins face, and another in May 2023 where White chased Garry before grabbing him, making him fall.

Mr Worsley read out a diary entry from Garry, dated from April 2025, which said: “He hammered me once again.”

Speaking directly to the jury, he said: “That’s how he treats someone who is close to him.”

The prosecution do not claim there was intent to kill Garry, but there was intent to cause serious harm.

During the trial, it was heard that White initially lied to the police about his criminal history, which the defence stated was due to him being “fearful” they would assume he was the one who assaulted Garry.

Miss Geraldine Kelly KC, defending, said: “We live in the real world - where people all too readily jump to conclusions.”

She told the jury that White’s previous assaults against Garry was of “low level violence” from what's alleged in this case, and that he “expressed remorse” for the injury caused in the incident which took place a couple of days prior.

She said: “He did actually care for his cousin - the history between them is not such that he’d ever intended causing his cousin really serious injury.”

The defence also asked the jury not to rule out the possibility that Garry was assaulted by another party, stating there is “scope” in the evidence.

White has displayed uncertainty over when and which direction Garry would have left the campsite in the middle of the night, but the defence highlighted “the stress he was under” and that he made assumptions over what happened because of his knowledge of his cousin’s drug use.

The jury was told how upon examination of his injuries, he was found to have “scratches” that “could be consistent” with branches and plants, which the defence suggested could be caused by him leaving the campsite in the night, which was surrounded by thick shrubbery and overgrown nettles.

At 6.40am on June 1, White reportedly called 999 and carried Garry to a place where paramedics could have access to help him. Miss Kelly KC submitted that at this point, the fatal injury of a punctured lung could have happened as White carried him.

She said: “What happened to Garry is tragic and sad, for him and his family.”

The trial continues.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice