Extra time winner nets a magical Montagu Cup 'first' for Wickersley

UNDERDOGS Wickersley CC have become the first team from their village to win the historic Mexborough Montagu Cup.

They shocked Gate Inn 2-1 in front of 1,475 spectators at Mexborough Athletic to lift the coveted trophy.

The Easter Monday final has a habit of producing shocks and the 2026 version is another to add to the list, sealed in dramatic fashion by an extra time winner from Ben Thornton.

“What a performance from the boys,” said the new champions. “It was a very cagey final but one we deserved to win in the end.

Champions: Wickersley CC with the Mexborough Montagu Cup. Picture by Julian Barkerplaceholder image
Champions: Wickersley CC with the Mexborough Montagu Cup. Picture by Julian Barker

"Our defensive unit was different class and we matched their physicality and intensity.

"We needed more composure in the final third but had it when it mattered the most.”

Helped by player manager Kallum Nix and others, Wickersley have done it the hard way, beating Westville in the semi and now Gate, who are clear at the top of the Rotherham Sunday League and through to the final of the Sheffield Sunday Senior Cup.

The victors are also the first side from the Blades Super Draw League to win the Mont in its 129 years.

Cool finish: Ben Thornton steers in the winner for Wickersley CC. Picture by The Dribbling Codeplaceholder image
Cool finish: Ben Thornton steers in the winner for Wickersley CC. Picture by The Dribbling Code

Wickersley started brightly and got the boost of an early goal when Louis Seddons’ low ball in was diverted into his own net by Jack Greeves.

Inside 60 seconds Greeves almost redeemed himself with a header from a corner which Pete Smith superbly turned away.

The early setback had jolted Gate into decisive action and they should have levelled only for Steve Taylor to put a great chance wide.

The equaliser did come on the half-hour, Nathan Walsh lifting an effort past the advancing Smith and Jordan Pilling helping himself to one of the Mont’s easiest-ever goals from about a yard out.

Tug of war: A spot of shirt pulling in the Montagu Cup final between Wickersley CC and Gate Inn. Picture by Mike Baylyplaceholder image
Tug of war: A spot of shirt pulling in the Montagu Cup final between Wickersley CC and Gate Inn. Picture by Mike Bayly

Josh Hemmingway and Josh Stead both fired over but Wickersley went closest right on half time, Reece Dudhill clearing off the line from a header by Liam Tomlinson.

The teams cancelled each out in the second half, Gate’s Greeves powered a header straight at the keeper and both Seddons and sub Dec Mullane could gave snatched it late on for Wickersley.

Thornton fired just over following a free-kick at the start of extra-time and Taylor almost broke the deadlock moments after the second period started.

With thoughts turning to penalties and 115 minutes on the clock, a Gate threat was checked inside the area and from deep inside his own half, Mullane’s longest of long balls drifted on the breeze, down the famous slope and, suddenly, Thornton’s eyes lit up.

He realised that the ball was carrying beyond his marker and he eased onto it and was clear.

Breaths were held… time stood still… but the veteran striker kept a cool head and side-footed calmly wide of the advancing Hayden Barnett and just inside the left hand post.

Gate looked stunned, couldn’t mount a late surge and so Wickersley went into the history books.

Thornton was named Man of the Match, edging out outstanding centre-half Nathan Taylor.

The result also completed a personal hat-trick for the match winner because he was in the AFP side which won the Mont in 2014 and 2016 (also scoring in that one).

No-one could begrudge Wickersley their triumph while Gate will now go in search of other prizes.

Wickersley CC: Smith; Kelly, Taylor, Cuckson, Claxton; France (McGann 105), Tomlinson (Nix 105); Hardeman (Mullane 60), Daughtry, Seddons (Godley 118); Thornton. Unused: Kemp.

Gate Inn: Barnett; Dudhill, Ardron, Greeves (Hough 68), Blackwood; James (Middleton 117), Hemmingway (Hancock 100), Stead; Pilling, Walsh, Taylor. Unused: Moore.

Referee: Roger Webb (Mexborough)

Attendance: 1,475

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice