Rotherham survivor calls for apology over barrister’s words in tribunal case
"On what level would he understand how much importance the questions hold? He cannot comment on that unless he is one of us"
A survivor of child sexual exploitation has called for an apology after a barrister representing Rotherham Council said requests for information about the town's abuse scandal by a campaigner had 'no value or serious purpose'.


The requests came from letters campaigner Liam Harron sent to council leader Chris Read in January 2024, about the authority's handling of child sexual exploitation. Some questions referred to the council's decision about distributing Voices of Despair, Voices Of Hope, a publication Mr Harron co-wrote about experiences of survivors and families.
The barrister argued that the particular requests at issue in Mr Harron's appeal stemmed from the dispute over the publication. In her written response to the tribunal, the survivor quoted the passage she wanted withdrawn.
It began "in relation to these questions" and went on "the requests have no value or serious purpose. They do not seek answers of importance to the victims of the child sexual exploitation scandal in Rotherham."
The survivor wrote: "On what level would he understand how much importance the questions hold? He cannot comment on that unless he is one of us"
At a cabinet meeting on Monday, November 16, she told council leader Chris Read she had asked the barrister to withdraw the comment and apologise for "discrediting and devaluing the victims' and survivors questions".
The tribunal, which heard Mr Harron's appeal in March, said whether victims would be interested or not was 'not the relevant test'. Looking at the requests on the whole, it ruled that the council was allowed to refuse them as vexatious, although it should have sent Mr Harron a a formal refusal notice.
Coun Read told Mr Harron he had tried to engage with him 'in good faith' over the years, and that some of his emails contained questions he could not answer.
Responding to Mr Harron's suggestion that a conversation could help avoid further legal costs, Coun Read said Mr Harron had spent years pursuing information though legal proceedings with the council. He said he could not intervene in said legal proceedings.