Demolition order for flats sparks fresh round of controversy
A LONG-RUNNING dispute over the future of a block of flats has taken a new twist with the owner challenging a planning decision which could see them demolished.
Rotherham councillors rejected a retrospective application for the block of nine flats in Shelley Road, Herringthorpe, in August and last month the authority issue a notice that they must be demolished.


A two year deadline was set for that, to allow current occupants’ tenancies to expire.
But now an appeal has been launched against the decision to refuse planning consent.
Residents, who have complained the flats were too close to their homes and caused overlooking, have pledged to fight the appeal.
Details of the case are complex, dating back decades and it emerged only relatively recently the, although the planning process had been started, permission was never obtained.
October’s order from Rotherham Council requires the owner to: “Demolish the three storey building and remove all materials used in its construction permanently from the site”.
The notice gave an opportunity for an appeal to be launched, however, and that has now been done.
An appeal statement, made on behalf of Mr S Hussain, states that he had previously relied on ‘planning experts’ and - according to his current representatives - “it appears as though the appellant has been let down at various stages, with agents not making minor revisions to ensure the building gains an approval, or failing to follow up on applications”.
The site had been given planning permission in principle before it was bought by Mr Hussain. However, detailed plans were not approved before the building went up and was eventually occupied.
By 2011, the planning application was “treated as withdrawn” by the council, because progress with the application had come to a halt.
An appeal statement suggests that councillors who made the decision to refuse permission were responsible for “ignoring planning commentary or focusing on items that we’re already proved to be complied with.
“I can only assume base on emotional (and inaccurate in the appellant’s opinion) testimony from objectors.”
The statement suggests the flats are “complimentary to the residential character of the area” and that there is “an identified need for housing in the Rotherham area”.
The case is expected to be decided by an independent planning inspector.