Decision due on controversial housing plan

PLANS for more than 200 homes are being recommended for approval - despite the land not being earmarked for immediate development and objections from the area’s three councillors.

Under the proposal, consent would be given for 230 homes on greenfield land off Pit Lane in Wombwell, with details of the development to be decided later.

Safeguarded: But planners recommend developmentplaceholder image
Safeguarded: But planners recommend development

Barnsley Council planners are recommending the application is approved - despite excluding the land from immediate development under a blueprint which will remain in place until the 2030s.

Wombwell’s three local councillors have all objected, submitting a report to the planning board, which will make a decision.

The council’s apparent u-turn on recommending the development is, in part, due to the failure of its Local Plan, a wide-ranging document to guide where new housing and industry should go in the years ahead.

It was adopted in 2019, but councils need to be able to show an adequate supply of land is available for new housing in the five years ahead, for it to carry full legal weight.

Barnsley Council now concede they cannot meet that criteria, which leaves the authority painted into a corner, because developers - who would be contributing to the ‘five year’ land supply rule - are much more likely to win permission for projects beyond the scope of the local plan, should they be rejected and go to appeal.

The Pit Lane site is largely land earmarked as ‘safeguarded’, meaning the council could have been open to potential development in future local plans.

A report to councillors who will decide on the application states: “On balance, and having regard to the council’s lack of housing land supply….. it is considered that there are no adverse impacts identified that would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the substantial benefits associated with housing delivery.”

Not all agree, however. In addition to the three Wombwell councillors’ objections, three dozen others have complained of issues around traffic and highway safety, the impact on wildlife, flooding, lack of school capacity and other issues.

A ‘safeguarded’ site at Hemingfield was rejected by the council for planning permission, but won at appeal because of the land-supply situation.

The council accepts that rather than a five year supply, there is currently only enough to satisfy demand for 2.9 years.

Councillors will decide on February 24.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice