New board member Phil Smith on the possibility of relegation and what Rotherham United's overall aim should be
NEW man Phil Smith surveyed Rotherham United's standing in the EFL pyramid and had the following to say about the Millers and their prospects in all of the four divisions.
Premier League: Planning for that would be “utterly bonkers“ ... although he doesn't see anything wrong with holding the ambition of one day getting there.


Championship: Staying in it for an “elongated period” and then “really competing” is what the club should aspire to do.
League One: Drop-zone Rotherham still have it in them to finish this season in mid-table.
League Two: Financially, dropping into it would hold no fears, although everything must be done to try to stay in a higher division for the sake of the fans.
Smith is the Kimberworth-raised wealthy businessman and boyhood supporter who has joined the Millers board as an ‘independent non-executive director’ to help owner Tony Stewart find ways of improving how the club can be run.
Rotherham are in a battle to stay in the third tier as they enter the final third of the campaign.
When asked about the importance of not slipping down to the division below, he replied: “It depends how you look at that, There are two different angles.
“From a fan perspective, which is uppermost in everybody's mind, you don't want another demotion, having come down from the Championship into League One.
“You do not want to fall into League Two, which is, in all fairness, a level below what this club is. So, we want to be looking up at the Champ, not looking down at League Two. And we've got the squad that should have us comfortably staying up.
“Now, if you look at it from a business point of view, it's very interesting how football finances work. I think that, if I'm being really honest with you, it's more of a challenge economically for the club to go into the Champ than it is to fall back into League Two. So there's no negative fear of that from an economic point of view.
“But of course, as I stress, we're looking upwards. It's about how we shape the economics of the club so that we can stay in the Championship for an elongated period, build upon that and then really compete.
“It's about following some of the previous clubs that have done that very effectively - Barnsley some seasons back and Luton a couple or three seasons ago. You've also got your Brentfords of the world who've done it.
“There's absolutely no reason why, with sensible economic management and great on-field coaching, Rotherham can't punch well above their weight in the years to come.”
Stewart has been at the helm for more than 17 years. The last two of those have brought disappointing fortunes on the pitch but, prior to that, under his leadership the Millers had won five promotions, spent seven seasons in the second tier and had four trips to Wembley.
During his time at the helm, he has often said that reaching the top flight - “the promised land”, as he refers to it - is his goal.
Smith said: “Tony's mentioned that a number of times. I've heard him - as a fan myself - talking about it. And that's because he's trying to stretch belief and enthusiasm for the club.
“He's realistic about where we are and in what way we can punch. But the truth is, it's not impossible. If we get a good squad together that we can hold in a consistent shape for a period of time, and then bring that performance out on the field, anything can happen.
“Now, are we economically planning to be in the Premier League? Absolutely not, that would be completely bonkers.
“But we are planning to be in the Championship and to be able to compete in the Championship at a budget size which is relevant to the demographics of Rotherham as a town and the economic potential of the club.”
The appointment of Smith, a long-time sponsor of the Millers, had been in the pipeline for a while and was made official earlier this month following approval from the EFL.
An avowed admirer of manager Matt Hamshaw, he already has one eye on next term as he bids to play his part in restoring Rotherham to their former lofty position.
“Me coming on board is much more about the 2026/27 season,” he said. “It's about what we do between now and then, how we do things in the (summer) transfer window and how we get right on the front foot.
He firmly believes that the club won't suffer relegation, saying: “I genuinely think that if we have a sprint through the back end of this season, given the tight spread of this league, we could still get up to mid-table, top 10 possibly.”