Shop plan approved for former pub despite fierce opposition
Widespread local opposition to shop plan overruled by councillors
A former pub - not used since the Covid-19 pandemic era - has gained permission to be be converted to a shop, but councillors insisted on tighter restrictions.


It means the former Sportsman, in Fitzwilliam Road, Swinton, can be used as a convenience store, with accommodation elsewhere in the building.
But the decision was only taken after a long - and at times heated - discussion by councillors on Rotherham Council’s planning board.
Planning officials had suggested restricting opening times to 7am and 11pm seven days a week.
But residents who attended the meeting spoke of problems with anti-social behaviour which already exists in the area, and their fears that a late-opening shop might exacerbate those problems.
Cllr David Fisher suggested cutting the opening hours with 10pm closing six days a week, and 9pm on Sundays.
The meeting was told another store nearby closed at 9.30pm, but that was the choice of the business, rather than a condition set by the council.
A planning application made several years ago was rejected over highway concerns, because of the use of a small customer car park.
That has now been removed from customer use, restricted to staff and residents, with council officers satisfied the reason for refusal had been answered.
But those who spoke at the meeting, and some councillors, raised issues with parking congestion in that area - with buses using a stop outside the Sportsman having to pull up further away due to stationary vehicles - and the expectation that customers might cause further parking problems.
Objections were raised by 47 people, along with a petition of 154 names, before the application went before councillors.
Resident Alexis Lawrence told the meeting: “I believe this particular shop is neither needed or wanted in this area.”
Officials said the application met the test in planning terms that a shop was needed in the area, and Cllr Paul Thorp accepted there was no planning reason to reject the application - but he did suggest it was a “disastrous thing” to open a shop which locals might choose to boycott, stating he supported the condition of reduced opening times.
Cllr Gregory Reynolds told the meeting: “We are desperately short of houses, we are not short of shops.
He became embroiled in an exchange with board chair Cllr James Mault, who said his colleague’s arguments were drifting into a “hypothetical” situation the board was not in a position to discuss.