Firm fined £36,000 for multiple safety breaches

Sheffield Crown Court was told today that Meadowbank Vac Alloys — which was fined £36,000 and ordered to pay £36,000 costs — was a serial safety offender.

The firm, based at the Meadow Bank Industrial Estate, allowed employees to operate vehicles and plant with category 'A' defects — the highest possible level — and continued to keep the machines in use even after being specifically prohibited from doing so by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE).

Twenty enforcement notices were served by HSE at the end of May 2012 after a visit by inspectors to the firm’s site in Harrison Street.

The visit was prompted by a complaint voicing concern about the condition of the firm's vehicles.

The notices covered a multitude of safety and health risks ranging from improvements needed to a variety of plant and lifting machines to the provision of basic welfare facilities for staff.

The court heard that there were a further four visits by HSE between then and early August when additional enforcement notices were issued.

These included seven which banned use of three forklift trucks, three mechanical grabs and a loading shovel that had no brakes.

All had category A defects, identified by an independent engineer.

Although numerous extensions of time were granted by HSE to Meadowbank Vac Alloys to comply with the enforcement notices, the company continually failed to take adequate action and workers had to operate the defective machines, the court heard.

The HSE identified that on two occasions in July and August, prohibited machines were still being used.

None of the defects had been rectified and again the company director was informed specifically what was needed for the notices to be complied with.

During an inspection in October 2012, officials found the dangerous loading shovel still in use and with some 80 hours’ working time clocked up when it should have been idle.

In total 31 notices were served between 29 May and Aug 2012, identifying 57 safety breaches.

Meadowbank Vac Alloys admitted a single breach of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 and multiple breaches of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 — three relating to Prohibition Notices and two for offences of non-compliance with Improvement Notices.

HSE inspector Denise Fotheringham said afterwards: “Meadowbank Vac Alloys displayed a reckless disregard for the safety of its employees and a persistent contempt for the legal notices issued requiring the firm to bring equipment to an acceptable standard.

“We exercised protracted patience with the company and were in regular contact with the director to ensure what was needed to comply was clear, unambiguous and fully understood.

“Despite being given ample opportunity, Meadowbank chose to ignore their responsibilities, put workers in danger on a daily basis, defy the law and turn a deaf ear to information, advice and guidance conveyed by inspectors and an independent engineer.”