Appeal fails to save apartment block from demolition order
Major development in long-running planning dispute
An apartment block built without planning permission on a housing estate appears doomed to demolition after an appeal to save the building was dismissed by a government inspector.


The decision appears to bring to a close a long-running wrangle over the building, built on land close to homes on Shelley Road, at Herringthorpe.
Under an order from Rotherham Council - now upheld by a planning inspector - a two year deadline was set from October last year for the building, which has nine apartments, to be cleared of occupants and demolished, with all debris removed from the site.
Planning permission for the development had been sought in the early years of this century but the process was never concluded and by 2011, Rotherham Council treated the application as withdrawn.
It only emerged in 2021 that the building had gone up without permission and while a planning application was made, in an attempt to formalise the situation, it was rejected by councillors on Rotherham Council’s planning board, amid concerns from neighbours of overlooking from residents in the three-storey block.
An appeal was lodged by Shabeer Hussain on two grounds, though one of those was dropped, leaving the argument that removing the building was excessive.
However, planning inspector Mark Caine found: “There is little before me to explain why the appellant considers the steps to be excessive or to detail any proposed lesser steps.”
Originally, Mr Hussain had proposed to also argue that planning permission should have been granted, but that element of his appeal was withdrawn before the inspector ruled on the matter.
That meant Mr Caine was “unable to consider the planning merits of the development”.
That would have included “the lengthy and drawn out planning history of the site, matters such as drainage, overlooking, privacy and access, and the misunderstandings and alleged injustices served to the appellant during the determination of the planning applications,” he said in his findings.
Before planning board members made their decision, council planning officers had recommended a retrospective application to approve the apartments should be granted, on the grounds that concerns about the block had been reduced by changes, including the reconfiguration of some flats and the removal of balconies and use of obscured glass.
In addition to overlooking, neighbours had complained of issues including the use of powerful flood-lights, the behaviour of some residents and an increase in litter and vermin.