Gravestone colour ban rift goes on between church and Rotherham family
A GRIEVING family which has not been allowed to put up a gravestone featuring coloured artwork has said the decision is unfair and claim that other memorials in the graveyard have been allowed colour.
As reported previously, a gravestone for Declan Francis Knight and Peter Knight was deemed out of order by church authorities when the family wanted to erect it at St Mary’s Church in Catcliffe.
The Chancellor of the Diocese of Sheffield ruled that colour on headstones was not allowed and that if the family wanted to appeal it would cost them £12,000.
Since then no memorial has been put in place for Declan, who died aged four days in 1999, and Peter, who died aged 67 in 2019.


Vanessa Wright, the daughter and auntie of Peter and Declan respectively, told the Advertiser that the Diocese had told them that coloured artwork wasn’t allowed because it upsets people.
But the family say that other gravestones have been set up with colourful artwork since they asked for, and were not allowed to have, a blue teddy bear and a yellow train.
Vanessa said that the family is angry that the Diocese has not contacted them over the issue recently.
She said: “I’m fuming that they haven’t responded.
“And I think they haven’t because they know it looks bad on them that some get allowed (to have colour on gravestones) and some don’t.”
Vanessa said that she had received support and comments from other people who were dissatisfied at the church’s stance.
She said: “Other people have said they have had ornaments and things removed from the graves as apparently they are not allowed.
“Others have said they have been turned down for a bit of colour too.
“I feel like to them it really seems to be about money.
“They are trying to play God.
“I’m so upset because I don’t see why some people have had what colour they want and five years later we are still fighting.”
In our previous report, Rev Philip Barringer, Team Rector and Oversight Minister on the Rivers Team, said that neither he as the incumbent at the church nor the Parochial Church Council had raised any objection to the family’s proposed memorial “because we recognise that there are a number of such memorials already present in St Mary’s churchyard and, therefore, we did not consider this proposals to be out of character”.
But he had been forced to say no to comply with the Chancellors Churchyard Rules 2024 which forces the incumbent of a church to permit only memorials that are compliant with Diocese rules.
A spokesperson for the Diocese said: “The Diocese of Sheffield recognises how upsetting and distressing decisions about churchyard memorials can be for bereaved families, particularly where families wish to include colour or personal symbols to reflect the life of a loved one. These feelings are understood and treated with compassion.
“However, Church of England churchyards are consecrated land. They are shared, sacred spaces for the whole community and are governed by ecclesiastical law.
“Memorials in such churchyards are therefore subject to legally binding Churchyard Rules issued by the Chancellor of the Diocese, who is the independent ecclesiastical judge responsible for these matters.
“The purpose of the Rules is to ensure that churchyards are places that exude respect for those who have died and comfort to those whose loved ones are buried and commemorated in that place. They should be an oasis for their communities, provide a sense of history and be a proper setting for the church and the memorials. They should be places where people can come to pray, to remember and, wherever possible, to find beauty, quiet and peace.
“Under the Diocese of Sheffield Churchyard Rules 2024, memorials are expected to be of natural stone in muted, traditional colours.
“Bright or decorative colour, non-traditional stone colours, certain images or photographic designs are not permitted under delegated authority.
“Clergy, including incumbents and area deans, do not have legal power to approve memorials that fall outside these Rules. Where a proposal does not comply, it must be referred to the Consistory Court for the Chancellor to consider by way of a faculty application.
“While some churchyards contain memorials that would not meet current legal thresholds, the Church cannot lawfully continue an illegal practice simply because it occurred in the past. To do so would place clergy in breach of their legal responsibilities and risk future distress if memorials were later challenged.
“The Diocese encourages families seeking something outside the Rules to use the faculty process, which allows the Chancellor to consider each case carefully, pastorally and lawfully.”
Rev Phil Barringer said: “Our deepest sympathies are with the family at this very difficult time, and we are sorry the matter is continuing to cause a great deal of stress and anxiety.
“We are not aware of any colour engraving or lettering having been permitted in the churchyard other than by faculty since the family applied for their faculty.
“Any requests for memorials that cannot be permitted under the delegated authority of the Diocese of Sheffield Churchyard Rules 2024 require faculty permission and are therefore referred to the Consistory Court.”