Fresh doubts over future of threatened apartment block

THE future of a controversial apartment block in Rotherham has become increasingly uncertain – with the failure of a planning appeal which could have saved it.

The block of nine flats was constructed without planning permission, after an application made in the early years of this century was never completed.

Failed: An appeal to save these apartments has been rejectedplaceholder image
Failed: An appeal to save these apartments has been rejected

That only came to light relatively recently and councillors on Rotherham Council’s planning board threw out a retrospective – or backdated – application last year.

Neighbours had complained that the block was overbearing and left occupants able to overlook their homes and gardens – the decision will come as a victory to them.

The original ruling opened the door for enforcement action – which could ultimately mean the building being demolished if all legal processes to keep it are exhausted.

The applicant behind the development made an appeal to the government’s planning inspectorate in an attempt to have the council decision overturned.

That has been rejected by an inspector who visited the site – on the grounds that suggested remedial work would not solve the problems, either for neighbours or apartment occupants.

It had been suggested removing balconies, obscuring glazing and reconfiguring the rooms inside some flats would provide an answer to overlooking complaints.

Dismissed: An inspector has rejected arguments to save these flatsplaceholder image
Dismissed: An inspector has rejected arguments to save these flats

However, the inspector ruled that having partially obscured windows would still leave occupants able to look out over a neighbour’s home and that fully obscuring glazing would be detrimental to anyone living in the apartments concerned.

The inspector also had to address the issue of human rights, because the apartments were occupied – including some with children.

It was acknowledged the inspector had to consider the occupants’ right to a home and best interests of a child.

But the inspector confirmed they were “qualified rights” and said: “I have found that the development would have a harmful effect to the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, with specific regards to privacy.

“In consideration of whether a planning condition would overcome this matter, I conclude that this would result in inappropriate living conditions to the occupiers of the development.

“It is not appropriate to refrain from intervening in these rights simply because the development is already occupied and may be affected by this decision.”

When councillors rejected the application, they were told enforcement action – meaning demolition – would be needed.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice